First Amendment rights are finally making it to Harvard Medical students, whose
interactions with the media will no longer have to be cleared by the school's
administration. The policy had required that students' contact with the media,
even conversations about their own projects and pursuits, be approved by both
the Office of the Dean of Students and the Office of Public Affairs. The policy
was enacted in February, but not promulgated until August 25th via an email
from Dean for Medical Education Jules L. Dienstag. When investigated by NYT
journalist Duff Wilson, officials at Harvard Medical "did not deny that
the policy was prompted in part by student remarks earlier this year about the
influence of pharmaceutical companies on medical education." The shift in
policy appears to be prompted in part by Wilson's investigation.
Other Harvard students have not been restricted like this, but the policy is
unsurprising to Harvey Silvergate, co-founder of the Foundation for Individual
Rights in Education. Silvergate blames the new "corporate" model of
university administration, in which fundraising and image branding take
priority over students' rights. Silvergate cites the replacement of one of Harvard
Law's student-edited publications with a new publication run by the
administration that is aimed at fund-raising and development.
More from the New York Times
More from FIRE
Issue: Free Speech and Academic Rights